We are reproducing the Editorial of “The Hindu” dated 23.11.2010 without
any comments.
JPC is an imperative
Insecurity,
unreasonableness ,and stubbornness tend to go hand in hand.Why else
should the
Congress-led government be dead set against allowing a
Joint Parliamentary Committe to try
and get to the bottom of the
2G spectrum scandal?With the report of the Comptroller and
Auditor
General of India exposing serious irregularities in the allocation of
2G
spectrum,resulting in staggering losses to the exchequer
,getting to the truth of what
happened has become a moral
imperative. While the Parliaments Public Accounts Committe
will
study the CAG report,this is no alternative to an empowered JPC that can
call for all
relevant records and summon Ministers,including the
Prime minister,for examination during
the course of its
enquiry.Moreover,it can probe the scandal in historical
perspective-against
he backdrop of telecom policy as it evolved,with twists and turns and
sometimes
carrying the stench of corrupton,over a decade and half.The governments
negative
response suggests a cover up.As it is evident from the observations of
the
Supreme court in the spectrum case,the Central Bueeau of
Investigation is not doing an
earnest job of investing the
matter.Nor will an enquiry by The Central Vigilance
Commission
carry conviction; the Supreme Court has questioned the appointment as
Central
Vigilance Commission of P J Thomas,who served as
Telecommunications Secretary during the
period of the scam and
has a charge sheeet pending against him.If,as the congress and the
Dravida
Munnetta Kazhakom insist,A Raja as communications Minister only
followed the 2G
spectrum allocation policy set by BJP led
National Democratic Alliance regimes,it is all
the more important
for a JPC to go back to the formulation of the National Telecom
Policy,1994
and enquire into everything of material relevance from then on.
An
empowered and well-staffed JPC has also become a political
imperative.The United
Progressive Alliance government faces a
crisis of credibility;Parliament has been rendered
dysfunctional;and
the image of the Prime Minister Manmohan Singh,a leader with a clean
personal
reputation,has taken a beating.If a JPC can work sincerely and in a
buisnesslike
way-on a day-to-day basis,more or less-all
significant facts relating to the 2G spectrum
allocation affair
can be placed before the people of India within the next two months.It
bears
recall that even the JPC set up to enquire into the Bofors
scandal,which nothing but
cover-upon its mind and was boycotted
by the Opposition,brought into public domain a mass
information
that proved invaluable to the Hindus investigation.That the BJP-led
govt.in
2001 did not concede the demand for JPC into the Thehelka
expose can be no justification
in the present situation.The
questions involved in the 2G scam are far too serious to be
allowed
to become part of the political tit for tat.